HOME EXPERTISE CLIENTS CONTACT ABOUT STEVE BLOG

Archive for February, 2008

ChittahChattah Quickies

Friday, February 29th, 2008
  • “We use the word sexy a lot and really have forgotten the ultra feminine.” Victoria’s Secret was launched with the idea that Victoria was manor-born and lived in London. That’s some pretty significant drift in image/meaning/story.


Fading Kitsch

Friday, February 29th, 2008

A few months ago we saw a very cool Hollywood used car lot, Kay Kars, featuring rather poorly executed (and dated) film icons as enthusiastic decoration.

kaykars5.jpg
kaykars6.jpg
A mural along one wall featured Brando, Marilyn, Clint, and Arnold.

kaykars3.jpg
kaykars2.jpg
kaykarspano2.jpg
A banner along the street showed some of the same classic stars, as well as Bugs and the Three Stooges.

kaykars4.jpg
Meanwhile, an otherwise non-famous bunny encouraged potential shoppers to “Come On In”

A few months along, Kay Kars has either moved or closed down (the website describes their luxury car inventory; not likely the same business) and the empty lot is nothing but sad.
img_0006.jpg
img_0007.jpg



ChittahChattah Quickies

Thursday, February 28th, 2008


ChittahChattah Quickies

Wednesday, February 27th, 2008


Ins and Outage

Wednesday, February 27th, 2008

img_1901.jpg
Starfucks sticker, Taipei, December 2007

Service outages seem to be common news stories lately. Sure, it’s news when many people in Florida lose power, but also when Pakistan causes a 2-hour YouTube blackout, BlackBerry service goes down, or Hotmail is unavailable.

There’s a sense that we are relying on far too many fragile systems and that as complexity increases, these stories will become even more commonplace (and perhaps even less newsworthy). But being forced to do without something seems to be a tactic companies enjoy using to extract a sense of the value of their service. The Whopper Freakout ad campaign is the most prominent example, but other companies such as Yahoo and Dunkin’ Donuts have conducted (consensual) user research experiments where people go without something and report back on the sense of loss.

But Starbucks pulled off the genius move, closing for a few hours to retrain staff, and making front-page news not for their failure (see: Florida, Blackberry, YouTube, Hotmail above) but for their retraining efforts towards a clarified service promise

Starbucks is welcoming customers back Wednesday with a new promise posted in stores: “Your drink should be perfect, every time. If not, let us know and we’ll make it right.”

This won’t address all of the challenges Starbucks is facing, but it’s a pretty brilliant P.R. success, hitting the denial-of-services hot button and emphasizing the valid, powerful reason behind the outage.



Design and Research had a baby and they called it . . .

Wednesday, February 27th, 2008

personal-greenhouse_no-tag.jpg
Sketches for “Personal Greenhouse” ©2007 Dan Soltzberg

Debbie Millman and Mike Bainbridge have posted their article, Design Meets Research, over at Gain: AIGA Journal of Design & Business. The piece provides a quick overview of various tools in the research toolbox, calls out their particular strengths and drawbacks, and makes the point that picking the right tool for the job and using it well are paramount.

Here are a couple of quotes from the article and some of my thoughts in response:

There are a wide variety of research techniques that can have merit for designers. . . There is not, repeat not, one correct way to test design.

I see research very much as a generative tool as well as an evaluative one, and have started to question whether the concept of a border between research and design is really accurate or productive. At the front end of the design process, research is a way of surfacing opportunities and generating ideas. At later stages, it’s a way of refining and validating these ideas as they become concepts and prototypes. In this way, research is a design tool in the same way that drawing is a design tool, except that at the center of the mechanism is the customer/user.

When used correctly, research shouldn’t stifle creativity but rather offer designers stronger inspiration and focus.

By taking a facilitative, collaborative approach to working with companies and design teams, research and research findings can be integrated into the design process in ways that enhance rather than stifle creativity. Keeping the customer/user and their needs prominent throughout the design process needn’t be limiting–having clear goals and constraints ultimately makes a design problem more interesting and leads to better, more elegant solutions.

And better, more elegant solutions are, after all, the end game here.



ChittahChattah Quickies

Tuesday, February 26th, 2008
  • Made of wheat bran, wheat, molasses, and corn dextrin, Postum was considered a “healthier” drink. It did not cause the jittery side effects that coffee gave some people. Kraft has stopped making it.
  • A demonstration of supposedly how people in different regions in the world count bills. The posture and gestures vary widely. One wonders these evolved so differently.


ChittahChattah Quickies

Monday, February 25th, 2008


ChittahChattah Quickies

Sunday, February 24th, 2008


ChittahChattah Quickies

Saturday, February 23rd, 2008


Where I’ll Be Speaking

Saturday, February 23rd, 2008

I’ll be teaching a one-day class on Design Research Methods on March 1, in Sunnyvale, CA. There’s a couple of spots still available, so if you want to contribute to a sell-out, it’s not too late!

You can see a longer version of my talk about improv and ethnography at the IDSA Southern Conference in Savannah, GA, March 6-8. See a previous talk here.

I’ll also be in Atlanta, en route to Savannah, and would love to meet up with people in that area to chat about the work we do and look for ways we might help you.

I’ll be giving a presentation called The Listener’s Journey at the Computer Market Analysis Group meeting at Intuit in Mountain View, CA, on March 13-14.

I will talk about international market research at the Silicon Valley American Marketing Association Morning Forum on March 18, in Burlingame, CA.

I will be giving a workshop on best practices in analysis and synthesis at the Second Annual eBay Visits Event on March 21, in San Jose, CA.

I will be giving a talk and hosting a workshop at a design research symposium at the College of Design at Arizona State University, April 11-13 in Tempe, AZ. I’ll be spending a day in Phoenix beforehand and would love to meet with people there explore ways we might be able to help your business.

Let me know if you’ll be at any of these events!



ChittahChattah Quickies

Friday, February 22nd, 2008
  • Leisa on the user’s experience when a system’s design fails to take into account your very reasonable and personal circumstances. Also see comments by Steve.
  • Even in 2008, software doesn’t accommodate those names; creating ridiculous hassle for travelers, voters, students, or anyone that has to “register” with a poorly designed system.
  • A small village in Kenya makes soapstone figures of The Simpsons characters. The carvings are available for online purchase. Most surprising is that they are an authorized licensee. (Thanks, Dan!)


Simulacrap 2

Friday, February 22nd, 2008

I already described the ridiculous persona-encrusted collateral from Yahoo’s Search Marketing. This week I received a package from Microsoft (with an unnecessary piece of styrofoam in the box to protect their precious wire-bound book).

searchmastersteve.jpg
With tips from me - Search Master Steve

Search Master Steve? Good Lord!

I’m not sure whether Microsoft’s only-works-in-IE search marketing interface is worse than Yahoo’s. I guess it’s like asking if you’d rather have two fingers ripped off by an angry gorilla or have three fingers removed surgically. These products are not fun to use and the crap I’m getting in the mail from the Microhooligans is insulting.



Fixtures

Thursday, February 21st, 2008

faucet-adaptation_sm.jpg
Bolts replacing missing handles, Omogari, San Jose, CA, November 2007



ChittahChattah Quickies

Thursday, February 21st, 2008


Friction Never Sleeps

Thursday, February 21st, 2008

sink.jpg
Sink handle too close to wall, Tully’s, Kyoto, Japan, January 2008

jr.jpg
Foot wear at the JR service counter, Tokyo, Japan, December 2007



ChittahChattah Quickies

Wednesday, February 20th, 2008
  • “Tiny UniBeads inside the straws dissolve and turn white milk into a healthy and delicious snack that everyone can enjoy.” Sounds horrible, but maybe perfect for kids. Healthy, I’m not so sure UniBeads are good for you. Thanks, CPT!
  • Whether this will usher in real change is up for grabs, but this is a powerful frame that has defined much of the TV experience forever; it no longer makes sense for the way we live our lives and NBC is breaking the frame.


Progress Bar

Wednesday, February 20th, 2008

The progress bar is a familiar interface widget in software. But sometimes it appears away from the PC.

dsc_0596.jpg
Crosswalk in Tokyo (full disclosure: I took the picture when the progress bar had run out; so I added them back in Photoshop).

dsc_0014.jpg
NEX train from Narita Airport to downtown Tokyo

dsc_0012-copy.jpg
Airport Express into Hong Kong



ChittahChattah Quickies

Tuesday, February 19th, 2008


Japan pictures - part 3 of 3

Tuesday, February 19th, 2008

I’ve uploaded nearly 1300 of my Japan pictures to Flickr. For reasons I’m sure you’ll understand, I haven’t added titles or tags or descriptions proactively, but please add comments or questions on flickr and I’ll gladly offer a story or explanation.

Meanwhile, I’m including some of my faves here, as well as part 1 and part 2.

2272934692_c599090146.jpg
2272667960_aba9c6e6ae.jpg
2268524205_a29e6fa897.jpg
2268545791_f9807f87d9.jpg
2257967397_e2b562ac95.jpg
2269371756_d26fc63275.jpg
2256791578_1c3d00c591.jpg
2253773720_178d142110.jpg
2252665417_70ff433a90.jpg
2252296839_50c3e93ba0.jpg
2239105805_49edecc355.jpg
2245298962_dd80f0c0bb.jpg
2246321101_41870c684f.jpg
2246788320_d17c9997a5.jpg
2248412431_f38a6ec9d9.jpg
2239009721_a76c660e85.jpg



Japan pictures - part 2 of 3

Tuesday, February 19th, 2008

I’ve uploaded nearly 1300 of my Japan pictures to Flickr. For reasons I’m sure you’ll understand, I haven’t added titles or tags or descriptions proactively, but please add comments or questions on flickr and I’ll gladly offer a story or explanation.

Meanwhile, I’m including some of my faves here, as well as part 1 and part 3.

2255975825_c605d108a8.jpg
2246191584_e2ff1002d6.jpg
2249533352_07c406b438.jpg
2277914474_c12b0330d6.jpg
2253903202_f4928b2f83.jpg
2253478944_c40076ea92.jpg
2271832533_ba870f1dca.jpg
2252247718_ef91043d06.jpg
2252260332_081bbb7fa0.jpg
2251454859_41f3b30a2f.jpg
2256014115_10ac8ef2b3.jpg
2248466293_8b73052053.jpg
2238917509_fb396e96c5.jpg
2268590815_e57ba228d3.jpg
2240004820_a0e6b3627d.jpg
2257477579_ed8a4db5ef.jpg



Japan pictures - part 1 of 3

Tuesday, February 19th, 2008

I’ve uploaded nearly 1300 of my Japan pictures to Flickr. For reasons I’m sure you’ll understand, I haven’t added titles or tags or descriptions proactively, but please add comments or questions on flickr and I’ll gladly offer a story or explanation.

Meanwhile, I’m including some of my faves here, as well as part 2 and part 3.

2277095015_22e7b9600a.jpg
2258550465_16b210c2a5.jpg
2253793394_45314527b8.jpg
2249755556_100b994904.jpg
2247594602_9b4c109c9a.jpg
2244478436_e0fbc2fd95.jpg
2240042192_781a6d5437.jpg
2239985198_1c2fa99899.jpg
2239283803_68ae5f7e9a.jpg
2275983797_c9daba24411.jpg
2268559025_12060527371.jpg



Real stories from real people inspire change

Tuesday, February 19th, 2008

Developments Magazine highlights an interviewing method that is part-historian, part-journalism, part-ethnography (and you could probably throw in participatory design and co-creation for a higher buzzword count). But the thrust is that stories, built from the details of the lives of real people are more effective drivers of change for advocates and policymakers and other stakeholders.

National newspaper, TV and radio journalists spent three days recording the lives of more than 30 rural people in Sindh province – people whose main qualification for being interviewed was their poverty.

These life stories were gathered by the Panos network and partners using a painstaking method of interviewing which emphasizes patient listening and open ended questions. The result was that those journalists are now more inclined to highlight the problems faced by the people they met and others like them.

These interviews were gathered using a method known as ‘oral testimony’, which sets out to record the fine detail of the lives of people in developing countries. This involves ‘active listening’ and encouraging the interviewee to dictate the direction of the interview.



ChittahChattah Quickies

Monday, February 18th, 2008


Sliding Doors

Monday, February 18th, 2008

broom.jpg
Public bathroom doorway, Karuizawa, Japan, January 2008

Before we hiked up the nearby mountain I wanted to use the bathroom. I was very frustrated to find the door locked. I pushed and pulled and saw the keyhole for the deadbolt and figured I was out of luck. Then I saw someone enter the adjacent women’s room - by sliding the door. I wouldn’t expect a bathroom door to slide, and I didn’t interpret any of the cues (or affordances) about how this door works to suggest sliding was a possibility.



Experienced pollsters know: people “lie”

Sunday, February 17th, 2008

As I’ve said before, garbage in, garbage out. From Rob Walker’s Consumed

Recently, Stardoll did a study of its own, polling United States users about their brand preferences. Apparently they saw real-world brands on the same plane as the half-dozen or so invented brands that exist only within the site. (Some respondents even made the — clearly impossible — claim that they wear the strictly digital Goth-style brand Fallen Angel to school.)

These sorts of stories always crop up in market research and business case studies. And they are wonderful because they illustrate the depth of meaning the products, services, brands, and stories we create can be to the people that consume them. So meaningful that they will conflate pretend brands online and tangible experiences offline. Wow, we marvel, that tells you how great our stuff is; they will lie about it.

But the flip side to that is that if you are going to ask people what they think and do and want, you better have a way of triangulating their responses against other data. If you don’t know more about the person than their response, how can you contextualize it? If you don’t know what they are really saying when they answer the question - if they understood the question or are answering it in the way you intended - then you must be very careful in what you conclude and how you act on those answers.



Simulacrap

Friday, February 15th, 2008

In my recent column Persona Non Grata I point to some of the cultural problems inside organizations that personas can create, or mask. And what happens when your personas become your marketing?

We’ve recently been experimenting with search marketing on Yahoo, MSFT, and Google. Today I received a shiny booklet from Yahoo, with a note from Sharon Goodsense, Yahoo! Search Marketing Specialist (”and remember, we’re always here to help you.”)
good.jpg

And I’m referred to as Bashful Beginner.
bash.jpg

Yahoo’s search marketing management interface is so completely useless that all I ever do is click and click and click until I get some result; with no mental model being built that would help me next time. I have no idea what most of the information they are providing is about or how I can use it. So maybe this book will help me, but the first two pages are the most patronizing and fake thing I can imagine. I can’t believe they went to the trouble to come up with these fake characters to represent the company I’m doing business with; it’s offensive to take my money for a service, give me an unusable product, and then hand me a cartoon character who talks down to me; if I can’t call this person for help with my problems, because they don’t exist. It’s the least transparent thing a company should do. Yahoo got off the cluetrain a while ago, I guess.



ChittahChattah Quickies

Wednesday, February 13th, 2008
  • Ah! A new kind of fatigue emerges: professional community fatigue. Interesting and slightly controversial perspective here: stop participating in your professional groups and go do some work.



































   ©2008 Steve Portigal       2311 Palmetto Ave., Suite D1, Pacifica, CA 94044             (415) 385-4171            Find us!